How To Value A Vacation Rental As An Investment & Find The Money Most Buyers Miss

I get this question a lot. How do you actually know if a vacation rental is a good investment? There are multiple ways to run the numbers, but here's how I do it.

The Formula

Start with the purchase price — that's your investment basis. Then list every actual operating cost: property taxes, management fees, utilities, maintenance, all of it. Next, pull the actual rental income from existing records, or estimate it if records aren't available. Subtract your total annual operating costs from that income and you have your net operating income. Divide that number by the purchase price and you've got your income return as a percentage.

Most people stop right there. That's probably a mistake.

Don't Forget Appreciation

The income return is only half the picture. The other half is what the property does in value over time. I like to look at a 10-year window of comparable sales and work out a reasonable average annual appreciation rate. Add that to your income return and you've got a rough total return estimate.

So if a property produces a 5% income return and appreciates at 5% per year, you're looking at something close to 10% annually on paper.

Use It to Compare Properties

This formula works just as well as a comparison tool. Run the same numbers on two or three homes and the best investment opportunity will jump right out at you. If you're exploring vacation rentals in Red River or Angel Fire, this approach gives you a clear, apples-to-apples picture fast.

It's also worth knowing how much you can realistically make renting your house before you run the numbers — income assumptions matter a lot.

Run the formula, compare the properties, and you'll know exactly where the real money is.

You Might Also Find These Helpful

 

Have questions or want to learn more? Give us a call at 575-613-4243 — we're happy to help. Rob Swan | Qualifying Broker | Swan Realty Inc.