The cost and availability of home insurance is starting to become a serious issue with those of us who own homes in the Red River and Angel Fire areas of New Mexico. There have been many stories on various Facebook groups of escalating premiums and outright cancellations.
I have been working on trying to find out what the real issue is and what we can do as homeowners to try and help our situation.
The Problem: Since the Calf Canyon fire that was started by the Forest Service in 2022 that burned over 300,000 acres and destroyed over 900 structures, insurance companies began reevaluating their risk exposure in the mountain areas of NM. and it appears that some companies deemed the risk to be too great and decided that they no longer wanted to insure our mountain homes. Others raised their rates or chose not to renew expired policies. Either way, this has caused rates to rise and availability to become more scarce and in some cases making it more difficult for folks to sell their homes.
Analysis: Historically, insurance companies assessed wildfire risk for homes based primarily on broad regional factors, meaning that all or at least most of the homes in any particular area were deemed to all have a similar risk to wildfires. With the advent of new technologies and AI models, the insurance companies are now looking at the actual home. A California based company by the name of Zesty.AI is providing much of this data to many insurance companies. When an insurance company receives a request from a consumer for a quote, the insurance company immediately sends the address to Zesty.ai or similar company in order to obtain a fire danger score. In the case of Zesty.ai, they will return to the insurance company a rating of red, yellow, or green. Red is non insurable, yellow is maybe upon further review, and green is approved.
One of the big issues with these ratings is that in most cases, the homeowner is never given any information as to why their house was rejected.
After speaking with multiple insurance company owners and experienced agents, I was able to compile some information that may be of use. One of the big things that make a home ineligible is the proximity to trees, for the most part, the preference is to have no trees within 30 to 40 feet of the home. Other factors are roof types, metal is preferred with composite being less desirable and one agent told me they cannot insure any house with rolled roofing. Other exacerbating factors include debris or firewood in close proximity to the house, untrimmed trees and brush nearby, and homes valued at over a million dollars. One agent I spoke with who represents one of the biggest companies in our country indicated that the lack of gravel or paved road access to the house may in the future make the house ineligible. There are also some non environmental factors that also contribute to premium rates and these include whether or not you have filed previous claims and believe it or not, your credit score.
Conclusion: It seems certain that the insurance availability for our mountain communities may be even more difficult in the near future. Abiding by some of the wildfire mitigation suggestions mentioned here may help you maintain or obtain a new policy. Swan Realty is currently working on automation that may cut down on the frustration of having to call multiple insurance companies to simply find out if your home is even eligible to be insured. Our plan is to allow our clients and homeowners to fill out a simple form that will then be automatically distributed to various agents to check eligibility. This will hopefully save a lot of time and frustration.
Real Estate Questions?
575-613-4243
Rob Swan
Qualifying Broker,
Swan Realty